Top Factors to Consider When Choosing New Countertops

Chelsea Myers
Sep 14
4 min read

When it comes to home improvement, few decisions are as impactful as choosing new countertops. The right countertops can transform the look of your kitchen or bathroom while also boosting functionality. With so many options available, the decision can feel daunting. In this guide, we’ll break down the essential factors to help you choose the best countertops for your home.

Material Options

The material of your countertops is one of the most critical aspects to consider. Different materials bring unique features to the table, affecting durability, maintenance, and aesthetics.

Granite: Known for its natural beauty and durability, granite is heat-resistant, making it perfect for kitchens. It comes in various colors and patterns. However, it typically requires sealing every one to three years to prevent stains. According to a recent survey, 70% of homeowners prefer granite for its long-term value.
Quartz: This engineered stone offers a non-porous and stain-resistant surface, which is ideal for busy kitchens and families. Its manufacturing process allows for a wide variety of colors and designs. With its growing popularity, quartz has gained a market share of about 30% among countertop materials.
Marble: While marble exudes elegance, it is softer than granite. It can scratch and stain more easily, which might make it less suitable for high-traffic areas. Twenty percent of buyers opt for marble due to its luxurious appearance.
Laminate: An economical option, laminate can mimic more expensive materials. It's easy to handle for DIY projects but may not have the same durability or heat resistance. With a starting price range of $10 to $50 per square foot, it remains a favorite for budget-conscious homeowners.
Butcher Block: Made from strips of wood bonded together, butcher block countertops add warmth and character to a kitchen. They can be sanded and refinished to extend their life, making them a durable and renewable option. However, they require regular sealing or oiling to resist water and bacteria. With prices starting around $40 per square foot, butcher block remains a popular choice for homeowners who want a cozy, natural look.

Consider the wear and tear your countertops will face based on your lifestyle. If you cook frequently or have young children, a more durable option like quartz or granite may be your best bet.

Style and Aesthetic

Your countertops should harmonize with your home’s overall design. Pay close attention to your color scheme, cabinetry, and flooring when selecting.

For modern spaces, sleek surfaces like polished concrete or quartz can enhance the minimalist vibe.
If you prefer a traditional aesthetic, classic materials like granite or marble with rich veining may fit perfectly.

It is also important to consider the finish of the countertops. Different finishes offer different appearances. A matte finish provides a subtle style, while a glossy finish can add an attractive shine and sophistication.

Maintenance Requirements

Different materials come with varying maintenance demands. Recognizing how much care you are willing to give your countertops is essential.

Granite and Marble: These require sealing to prevent scratches and stains, typically every few years.
Quartz: This option is very low-maintenance, needing only soap and water for cleaning.
Laminate: It is very easy to maintain and can be wiped clean without special products.
Butcher Block: This surface requires regular oiling or sealing to protect against moisture and bacteria, but it can be sanded and refinished to look like new.

For busy homeowners, a low-maintenance material like quartz or laminate could save you time and effort.

Budget Considerations

Budget is a major factor when choosing countertops. Costs can range dramatically based on the material, brand, and installation.

Premium materials like granite or marble can range from $40 to $200 per square foot, including installation.
Engineered stone options generally cost between $50 and $150 per square foot, depending on the brand and design.
Laminate, on the other hand, generally falls between $10 and $50 per square foot.
Natural wood countertops like Butcher Block usually range from $40 to $100 per square foot, depending on the wood species and finish.

Setting a clear budget will help narrow down your options and avoid unexpected expenses. Remember that while lower-cost materials might save money initially, investing in quality countertops often pays off in durability and attractiveness.

Installation Process

The installation of your countertops varies by material type. Some options, like laminate, can be tackled as DIY projects.

Granite and marble: These materials require professional installation due to their weight and the need for precise cutting. A professional installation can cost between $30 and $100 per square foot, depending on the complexity.

Discuss installation with your contractor to understand the costs and timeline, ensuring that your remodeling goes smoothly.

Environmental Impact

As sustainability becomes increasingly important, consider the environmental impact of your countertop choices.

Eco-friendly options like recycled glass or sustainable bamboo can significantly lower your carbon footprint.
Understanding the sourcing of natural stone is also crucial, as some quarries emphasize sustainable practices.

If sustainability matters to you, research materials that align with your values and contribute to a greener home.

Resale Value

Looking ahead, remember that your choice of countertops can influence your home's resale value.

Granite and quartz are often sought after by potential buyers, making them wise investments. Studies show that homes with high-quality countertops can see a return on investment of up to 80%.

Keep local market preferences in mind, as trends and desirable features can vary from one area to another.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, selecting new countertops is a blend of practical and aesthetic decisions. Each factor—from material selection and style to maintenance and budget—plays a role in your final choice. By thoughtfully considering your needs and preferences, you can select countertops that enhance the beauty of your home and serve practical purposes for years.

For the best results, communicate openly with your contractor to ensure your vision is realized beautifully.